Beyond rationality: in search of a broader view of the deliberative process

Abstract

In light of the widening of contemporary struggles for recognition, within

a context of greater visibility for new actors within public spaces, we have

been able to identify the limitations of the liberal model of democracy which

emphasizes, above all, legitimacy, power and rationality. This article proposes

to take a look at the wide range of criticisms of deliberative democracy,

particularly with regard to the use of rationality as the sole form of argumentation

and action. Our critique of the use of rationality is anchored in

Young’s (1990, 1997, 2001) and Hoggett and Thompson’s (2002) discussions.

The incorporation of other forms of action and communicative patterns

represents an attempt to make deliberative processes more inclusive, so

that they may truly become sites of equality and emancipation.

Keywords: Deliberative democracy, rationality, inclusion.