Institutional Interpretation of Human Rights: Critical Remarks

Nunzio Alì

Resumo


http://dx.doi.org/10.5007/1677-2954.2016v15n3p486

Some scholars believe that only governments or those who uphold governmental policies can be human rights violators. Others argue that private individuals (with no governmental mandate and acting for themselves) are also able to violate human rights. The two positions have come to be known in the literature as the institutional interpretation and the interactional interpretation of human rights respectively. This paper critically analyzes an exemplary case: Thomas Pogge’s institutional conception of human rights as presented in World Poverty and Human Rights: Second Edition. This paper focuses on some of the negative consequences implicit in his approach. First of all, it shows that Pogge does not provide an adequate explanation of the reason why human rights should be conceived as claims on coercive social institutions and on those who uphold such institutions but not on single individuals, independently of their commitment to institutions. Secondly, it shows that official disrespect rather than violation as a criterion to evaluate the respecting of human rights is unsuccessful or at least insufficient. It sees in Pogge the same perspective mistake that infects Rawls’ conception of human rights, namely that of expanding unduly one of the functions human rights perform - establishing the limits of legitimate sovereignty - into their very essence. Therefore, this paper puts in question the way in which Pogge’s institutionalism mix the conception of human rights with the conception of (global) distributive justice. The conclusion to which the whole paper comes to is that proponents of the institutional interpretation (at least in the case of Pogge) misconstrue human rights because they conflate two philosophical agendas, that of human rights and that of global justice.

 

 


Palavras-chave


Thomas Pogge; Human rights; Institution interpretation; Interactional interpretation; Global justice

Texto completo:

PDF/A (English)

Referências


ASHFORD, E. The Duties Imposed by the Human Right to Basic Necessities. In POGGE, T. (edited by) Freedom from Poverty as a Human Right. Who Owes What to the Very Poor?, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2007, pp. 183 – 218.

Barry, C. – Southwood, N. “What Is Special about Human Rights?”. Ethic and International Affairs, 25, 2011, pp. 1 -15.

BEITZ, C. R. Human Rights and The Law of People. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2004.

_______ The Idea of Human Rights. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2009.

BUCHANAN, A. “The Egalitarism of Human Rights”. Ethics, Vol. 120, No. 4, 2010, pp. 679-710.

_______. The Heart of Human Rights. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2013.

CANEY, S. Justice Beyond Borders: A Global Political Theory. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2005.

DORSEY, D. “Global justice and the limits of human rights”. The philosophical quarterly, Vol. 55, No. 221, 2005, pp. 562-581.

GRIFFIN, J. On Human Rights. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2008.

HABERMAS, J. “Kants Idee des Ewigen Friedens - aus dem historischen Abstand von 200 Jahren”. Kritische Justiz 28/3, 1995, pp. 293 -319.

HOHFELD, W. Fundamental Legal Conceptions. Yale University Press, New Haven, 1919.

JAGGAR, A, M. (edited by)Thomas Pogge And His Critics. Polity Press, Cambridge, 2010.

NAGEL, T. Personal Rights and Public Space. In NAGEL, T. (edited by) Concealment and Exposure & Other Essay, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2002.

NICKEL, J. Making Sense of Human Rights: Second Edition. Blackwell, Oxford, 2007.

_______. Human Rights. In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2003, pp. 13-15.

O'NEILL, O. Rights, Obligation and World Hunger. In POGGE, T. – HORTON, K. (edited by) Global Ethics: seminal essays, Paragon House, St. Paul, 2008, pp. 139 - 156.

POGGE, T. World Poverty and Human Rights: Cosmopolitan Responsibilities and Reforms. Polity Press, Cambridge, 2002.

_______. World Poverty and Human Rights: Second Edition. Polity Press, Cambridge, 2008.

_______. “Are We Violating the Human Rights of the World's Poor?”. Yale Human Rights & Development Journal, Vol. 14:2, 2011, pp. 1-33.

_______. “Are We Violating the Human Rights of the World’s Poor? Responses to Four Critics”. Yale Human Rights & Development Journal, Vol.17: Iss. 1, Article 3, 2014, pp. 74-87.

RAWLS, J. Political Liberalism. Columbia University Press, New York, 2005.

_______. The Law of Peoples. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 1999.

RAZ, J. Human Rights without Foundations. In BESSON, S. – TASIOULAS, J. (edited by), The Philosophy of International Law. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2010, pp. 321-338.




 

 

 

 

 

ethic@. Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Florianópolis, SC, Brasil, eISSN 1677-2954

Licença Creative Commons
This obra is licensed under a  Creative Commons Atribuição-NãoComercial-SemDerivações 4.0 Internacional