Children, their brains … and beyond: Reflections on a feminist ethic of research

Abstract

In interlocution with authors from the field of science studies as well as feminist theories of
care, I reflect on the ethical dilemma associated with the participation of social scientists in the
multidisciplinary arena of public policy. I build my analysis around an image frequently found in debates on child-protection policy that juxtaposes two infantile brains, one labeled “normal”, and the other ,“extreme neglect”. Upon tracing the unorthodox trajectory of this neuroscientific artefact through concrete actors and situations, I propose to reinforce a critical perspective of popularized forms of science that tend to ignore the value judgments implicit in any “scientific fact”. On the other hand, in a self-reflexive exercise, I seek to understand how the researcher’s “caring”, in its diverse manifestations, carries implications for the ethical and political becoming of the worlds under consideration.