Theories and experiments of an essay on fire
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5007/2175-7941.2021.e73715Abstract
The study natural phenomena of interest to society figures among the purposes of science teaching in Basic Education. It is surprising, therefore, that fire receives little attention in science and almost none in education. Even though fire most certainly represents one of the most fascinating manifestations of Nature none of the chemistry collections approved by the National Textbook Program (PNLD 2015) presents any in-depth study on it. But things were different in the past. In order to recover a particular detail of the history of fire as an object of study in chemical philosophy, in this paper we analyze the work An essay on fire, published in 1790 by the celebrated philosopher from Geneva, Marc-Auguste Pictet. Based on the contemporary historiography of science we seek to analyze how fire was explained by some late 18th century theories. The results of this analysis reveal aspects of interest on chemists' style of thinking in the studied context. Pictet's text makes it clear that the word fire was used to designate not only the flame, but an agent responsible for several effects on the structure of natural bodies, such as dilation, changing states of aggregation and chemical decomposition itself. Describing series of experiments, the philosopher analyzes fire from four points of view: liberated fire, specific heat, latent heat, and combined fire. All experiments are preceded by theoretical speculations and results are used as means to accept or to reject such theories. It is also noteworthy that Pictet's approach often oppose corpuscular and vibrational assessments on fire as the causal agency to the effect that we call heat. We conclude that the study of Pictet's work allows us to access some nature of science features, highlighting the importance of communication between researchers, the interdependence between experiments and theories, and the coexistence of different models to represent a phenomenon under study.
References
ALFONSO-GOLDFARB, A. M.; FERRAZ, M. H. M.; BELTRAN, M. H. A historiografia contemporânea e as ciências da matéria: uma longa rota cheia de percalços. In: ALFONSO-GOLDFARB, A. M.; BELTRAN, M. H. R. (Ed.). Escrevendo a História da Ciência: tendências, propostas e discussões historiográficas. São Paulo: Livraria da Física, EDUC, Fapesp, 2004. p. 49-73.
ALLCHIN, D. Phlogiston after oxygen. Ambix, v. 39, p. 110-116, 1992.
ALVES, E. A. Benjamin Thompson (Conde Rumford) e o experimento da radiação do frio. São Paulo: Pontifícia Unversidade Católica de São Paulo, 2015.
AUBIN, D. The Hotel that Became an Observatory: Mount Faulhorn as Singularity, Microcosm, and Macro-Tool. Science in Context, v. 22, n. 3, 2009.
BAHAR, S. Jane Marcet and the limits to public science. British Journal for the History of Science, v. 34, p. 29-49, 2001.
BALDINATO, J. O. Conhecendo a Química: um estudo sobre obras de divulgação do início do século XIX. 2015. Tese (Doutorado em Ensino de Ciências) - Universidade de São Paulo. São Paulo.
CAROZZI, A. V. The history of petroleum geology and the geneva naturalists (1790-1815). Journal of Petroleum Geology, v. 15, n. 1, 1992.
EVANS, J.; POPP, B. Pictet’s Experiment: the apparent radiation and reflection of cold. American Journal of Physics, v. 53, n. 8, p. 737-753, 1985.
KUHN, T. S. The Caloric Theory of Adiabatic Compression. Isis, v. 49, n. 2, p. 132-140, 1958.
KUHN, T. S. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago: University Press, 1962.
LAVOISIER, A. L. Tratado Elementar da Química. Tradução: Laís dos Santos Pinto Trindade. São Paulo: Madras, 2007.
LAVOISIER, A. L. Traité Élémentaire De Chimie. Paris: Chez Cuchet, 1789.
LETTRES d’Alexandre de Humboldt a Marc-Auguste Pictet (1795-1824). Memóires de la Société de Géographie de Genève, v. 7, p. 127-204, 1868.
LINDEE, M. S. The American Career of Jane Marcet’s Conversations on Chemistry, 1806-1853. Isis, v. 82, p. 8-23, 1991.
MARTINS, L. A.-C. P. História da ciência: objetos, métodos e problemas. Ciência & Educação, v. 11, n. 2, p. 305-317, 2004.
MORTIMER, E. F.; MACHADO, A. H. Química. São Paulo: Scipione, 2013.
PICTET, M.-A. Essais de Physique. Tome 1er. Genève: Barde, Manget & Co., 1790.
PICTET, M.-A. An Essay on Fire. London: Jeffery, E., 1791.
RABKIN, Y. M. Technological Innovation in Science: The Adoption of Infrared Spectroscopy by Chemists. Isis, v. 78, p. 31-54, 1987.
SIGRIST, R. Correspondance de Marc-Auguste Pictet (1752-1825) Tome III : Les correspondants britanniques. Version française inédite, 2015. Disponível em: <https://independent.academia.edu/RenéSigrist/Books>. Acesso em: 24 set. 2019.
SIGRIST, R. Correspondance de Marc-Auguste Pictet (1752-1825) Partie scientifique et technique Tome I : Les correspondants genevois. Version révisée, 2016. Disponível em: <https://independent.academia.edu/RenéSigrist/Books>. Acesso em: 24 set. 2019.
THOMPSON, B. New Experiments upon Heat. By Colonel Sir Benjamin Thompson, Knt. E. R .S. In a letter to Sir Joseph "Banks, Bart, P. R. S. Philosophical Transactions, v. 76, p. 273-304, 1786.
VAUCHER, J. P. Nécrologie. Notice sur Mr. M. A. Pictet. Bibliothèque Universelle des Sciences, Belles-Lettres et Arts, v. 29, p. 65-88, 1825.
VOLTA, A. Del modo di render sensibilissima la più debole elettricità. Philosophical Transactions, v. 73, p. 237- 280, 1782.
WATTS, I. P. Philosophical intelligence: letters, print, and experiment during Napoleon’s continental blockade. Isis, v. 106, n. 4, p. 749-770, 2015.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
DECLARAÇÃO DE RESPONSABILIDADE Certifico que participei da concepção do trabalho, em parte ou na íntegra, que não omiti quaisquer ligações ou acordos de financiamento entre os autores e companhias que possam ter interesse na publicação desse artigo. Certifico que o texto é original e que o trabalho, em parte ou na íntegra, ou qualquer outro trabalho com conteúdo substancialmente similar, de minha autoria, não foi enviado a outra revista e não o será enquanto sua publicação estiver sendo considerada pelo Caderno Brasileiro de Ensino de Física, quer seja no formato impresso ou no eletrônico.
Caderno Brasileiro de Ensino de Física, Florianópolis, SC, Brasil - - - eISSN 2175-7941 - - - está licenciada sob Licença Creative Commons > > > > >